Please review the General Instructions and our Judging Philosophy before you start your critique. You also should carefully review the background material for the yearbook. Thank you!

Fill out a critique via the online form

Click here to open the online form (for 2024 books)

Using the form

This form is built on the Qualtrics platform. Qualtrics uses cookies to save your work as you go. If you need to leave your work for an extended period of time, please skip ahead to the last page and submit your work so far. This saves your work so that you can return to it later. You will receive an email that will include a link that will allow you to revise what you previously have submitted.

If something goes wrong and you're forced to leave the form midway through without submitting, Qualtrics may have saved at least some of your work. If any portion was saved, Jeremy can help you retrieve it. Please call or email.

Worksheets

Over the years, we have found many judges prefer to type their commentaries in their favorite word processing program rather than typing directly into our critique form. This allows you to more easily save, edit and review your work. We have prepared Word and Google Doc worksheets to try to assist you with that. You can then copy and paste your work into our online form.

Re-evaluations

Click here to open the online form for 2023 books

Booklet for handwritten critiques or reference

Download a copy of our critique booklet for your reference.

PLEASE ONLY USE THE ACTUAL BOOK IF YOU ARE SUBMITTING A WRITTEN CRITIQUE ON PAPER.